The State of the Art Is Not a List of Previous Studies
Moving from collecting literature to building a map of knowledge
By Vilma María Pérez Viñas. TEXTUM. International Academic Mentoring
“I’ve already downloaded more than a hundred articles.”
The statement conveys a sense of progress: the researcher has searched for, selected, and stored a considerable amount of scientific literature. Yet when they try to explain what they have learned from that reading, a difficulty may emerge:
What do we really know about the problem I am investigating?
Having many articles does not necessarily mean understanding the existing knowledge. A review may bring together dozens of authors, theories, and findings without clearly showing what is known, what is debated, which aspects remain insufficiently explained, or where the researcher’s own study might fit.
The purpose of a state-of-the-art review, therefore, is not to demonstrate how much has been read. It is to build an organized understanding of the available knowledge that allows the researcher to position their study within it.
Finding literature is not yet building knowledge
A literature search helps researchers locate relevant scientific publications. But locating studies is not the same as understanding how knowledge about a problem has been developed.
Once relevant literature has been identified, researchers need to examine, among other things:
which perspectives have been used;
which problems have received the most attention;
which findings are consistent;
where discrepancies exist;
which methods have been used;
which contexts have been studied; and
which aspects remain insufficiently explained.
A literature search helps answer an initial question: What has been published?
A state-of-the-art review requires moving toward another: What can I understand about my problem from what has already been investigated?
The difference is not merely terminological. It changes the role the review plays in the research process.
Fig. 1. From Literature Analysis to Research Positioning
A succession of authors does not necessarily reveal what is known
One common way of presenting previous research is to summarize each study separately:
Pérez (2022) studied…
García (2023) found…
Rodríguez (2023) analyzed…
López (2024) noted…
The information may be accurate. The difficulty arises when the text becomes a succession of studies without explaining the relationships among them.
Readers may learn what each author said, but they do not necessarily understand:
where the studies agree;
how they differ;
which perspectives predominate;
which findings are in tension;
what changes can be observed; or
which questions remain open.
The researcher’s task is not simply to reproduce what others have said. It is also to organize and connect their contributions in order to interpret what they show collectively.
Studies contribute findings, concepts, and arguments; the researcher’s analysis establishes the relationships that make them understandable.
Organizing literature by author can obscure patterns
A chronological order may be useful, as may an organization based on theoretical perspectives, methodological approaches, contexts, or other relevant criteria. There is no single correct way to organize the literature; the choice depends on what needs to be understood.
What organization would best help me understand the knowledge developed about my problem?
Imagine a study on teachers’ digital competence. If the review is organized solely by author, it may become a long sequence of summaries. An analytical organization, by contrast, could help identify:
how digital competence has been conceptualized;
which dimensions have been studied;
which instruments have been used;
which educational contexts predominate;
which findings recur across studies; and
where differences among studies emerge.
The second approach does not necessarily gather more information. Instead, it makes the relationships among studies more visible. Those relationships make it possible to build an interpretation of the field rather than merely describe isolated publications.
Fig. 2. The Construction of the State of the Art as a Recursive and Interdependent Process
A state-of-the-art review needs analytical categories
Interpreting the literature requires more than collecting study summaries. Researchers need to define criteria or categories that allow them to examine studies consistently.
Depending on the research question and the nature of the study, relevant categories may include:
theoretical perspectives;
central concepts;
research problems;
contexts;
populations;
methodological approaches;
instruments;
main findings;
reported limitations; and
periods of research.
Not every category will be necessary for every study. The selection should respond to the research question and to what needs to be understood about the available knowledge.
A literature matrix can help organize information, but it is not, by itself, a state-of-the-art review. It is a working tool that can help identify relationships; those relationships must then be analyzed and interpreted.
A research gap does not mean that no one has studied the topic
This distinction deserves attention because it directly affects how a study is justified.
The fact that a topic has already been studied does not mean that further research is unnecessary. Likewise, claiming that “no studies exist on this topic” requires a sufficiently broad search and careful justification.
Often, the opportunity for research remains insufficiently developed.
For example, there may be:
a conceptual limitation, when a concept is used in divergent ways or remains insufficiently defined;
an empirical limitation, when the available evidence is still limited;
a methodological limitation, when certain ways of studying the phenomenon predominate;
a contextual limitation, when particular contexts or populations have received little attention;
discrepancies among findings, when different studies produce results that require explanation; or
an explanatory limitation, when certain outcomes are known but it is not sufficiently clear why or how they occur.
Identifying a research opportunity does not mean searching at all costs for a topic that no one has studied. It means specifying what needs to be better understood and justifying that need through an analysis of the literature.
From the state of the art to positioning the research
A well-developed review should make it possible to answer four questions progressively:
What do we know?
Which aspects are debated or produce divergent findings?
What remains insufficiently explained?
Where does my research stand in relation to this knowledge?
The last question connects the review to the study itself. No research begins from zero: a study develops in relation to existing knowledge, which must be understood critically in order to establish what the new study may contribute.
The analytical process is not a rigid sequence of stages. Searching, selecting, comparing, connecting, and interpreting influence one another. As researchers interpret studies, new questions may lead them to broaden the search, revisit selection criteria, or reorganize their analysis. Research positioning is built—and may be revised—as understanding of the field develops.
Positioning a study does not simply mean claiming that it is “new.” It means explaining where it fits within the available knowledge and which need for knowledge it seeks to address.
The literature review must also answer the research question
A review may be extensive and still have a weak connection to the problem being investigated. This happens when literature is included because it relates generally to the topic, without explaining how it helps address the study’s specific research question.
To assess the relevance of each body of literature, researchers can ask:
What does this study contribute to understanding my problem?
How does it relate to my research question?
What can I compare with other studies?
What difference, limitation, or possibility does it reveal?
How does it help position my research?
These questions guide the review toward interpreting knowledge and justifying the place the study will occupy.
Reading more may expand the set of sources consulted. But analyzing the relationships among studies is what makes it possible to understand the field more fully.
The TEXTUM perspective
At TEXTUM, we understand a state-of-the-art review as a process of analyzing and interpreting available knowledge in order to position a study within its field. Its purpose is not to assemble an ever-growing folder of articles or present a succession of previous studies, but to identify and interpret relationships among trends, agreements, differences, debates, limitations, gaps, and possibilities for further development.
A rigorous review does not conclude simply when a sufficient number of sources has been read. It concludes when the researcher can clearly explain what is known, what remains open, and why their study makes sense in relation to that knowledge. In this way, a state-of-the-art review does more than describe previous research: it helps establish the research positioning.
Have you gathered a great deal of literature but still find it difficult to explain where your research fits within what is already known?
The number of articles consulted does not, by itself, guarantee an understanding of the field.
TEXTUM’s academic mentoring can help you turn a scattered review into an organized analysis of available knowledge and more precisely establish where your research stands.
REVIEW MY RESEARCH POSITIONING
Are you using the concepts in your research precisely?
Identifying relationships among studies is essential to building a state-of-the-art review. It is also necessary to clarify the concepts we use to think about and organize what we investigate.
In the next article, we will address a key question in the methodological construction of a study:
Variables, Categories, and Dimensions: Are You Using Different Words for the Same Thing?